Someone please tell me whether I should make the astrakhan cardi from the Fall 05 Vogue Knitting (without the cash aran bits on the cuff and collar), or whether I should go for the shawl collared cardi in the Simply Soft book.

Here is a link to a pic of the shawl collar cardi – shawl cardi

And here is the Vogue Cardi courtesy of another knitting blogger (no one seems to have finished making this thing yet…).

I’m going to frog something and start this. I’m a baaaad girl.